Slavery and the Bible
by Jeremy Crump
Christians are understandably troubled to learn that
slavery was allowed in Israel under the Law of Moses. Moreover, neither
Jesus nor his apostles call for the abolition of slavery in the New
Testament. How is it that God could make laws about slavery in the Old
Testament and why does He seem to give tacit approval to it in the New?
Slavery in
the Old Testament
Slavery was common in the ancient world in which the
biblical writers lived. Indeed, the institution of slavery was unquestioned
everywhere in the world until modern times. A person could become a slave
after being captured in war, defaulting on a debt, as punishment for a
crime, being kidnapped, being born to slave parents, or they could become a
slave voluntarily if they were unable to support themselves. Unlike the
African slave trade of modern times, slavery in the ancient world was not
based upon race, but cut across all nationalities. Indeed, every race has
been enslaved at some point in their history. Treatment of slaves varied
among ancient cultures but, in general, the slave owner had total and
absolute rights over the slave's person; slaves were regarded as property
and stripped of their identity (racial, familial, social, marital, etc.).
Slavery in its various forms was present very early in
Israel's history. Israel the patriarch (i.e., Jacob) volunteered to be
Laban's slave in exchange for marriage to his daughter Rachel (Genesis
29:15ff). His son Joseph was sold into slavery by his brothers
(Genesis 37:28). The nation of Israel that came from his seed was forced
into slavery by the Egyptians (Exodus 1:8-14).
When Israel became a nation, God gave through Moses
laws concerning slavery (Exodus 21:1-11; Leviticus 25:39-55; Deuteronomy
15:12-18). Most of these are concerned with the fair treatment of
slaves. Behind every law was a reminder from God that Israel too had been
slaves in Egypt and thus they should treat their slaves fairly (Jeremiah
34:12-22). Slaves in Israel were of an inferior status but they were
still involved in society to a large degree. Slaves were not regarded as
less than human and their masters did not have total control over them. If a
master permanently injured a slave, the slave was to go free (Exodus
21:26-27). If a master killed a slave, the master was to be executed
(Exodus 21:20).
Hebrew slaves were released after six years of service
and given the means by their masters to start over. However, many of them
chose to remain in slavery for life (Exodus 21:1-6). On the Jubilee
Year (every 50th year), slaves were set free regardless of whether or not
their debts were paid. Slaves could also be redeemed at any time by their
relatives. Foreigners enslaved in Israel might be enslaved permanently, but
they were given the right to circumcision (Exodus 12:44-48), Sabbath
(Exodus 20:10), and other holidays (Deuteronomy 16:11, 14).
Fugitive slaves who had escaped from foreign owners were welcomed and not
extradited back to their owners (Deuteronomy 23:15-16), unlike the
Fugitive Slave Laws of the Antebellum South. Anyone caught taking another
person captive in order to sell him as a slave was guilty of a capital
offense under the Law of Moses (Exodus 21:6; Deuteronomy 24:7) and
this practice is condemned in the New Testament as well (1 Timothy 1:10).
God is explicitly said to have punished the Philistines and the Phoenicians
for taking whole nations captive to sell them as slaves (Joel 3:4-8; Amos
1:6-10; cf 2 Chronicles 21:17) and warns Rome in the New Testament that
they will be punished for their slave trade as well (Revelation 18:11-13).
The African slave trade of the nineteenth century would have fallen under
this criteria of condemnation.
Israel's fair treatment of slaves was unprecedented and
unmatched in the ancient world. Their laws stood in stark contrast with
other law codes from the same time period such as those of Ur-Nammu, Eshunna,
Lipt-Ishtar, Hammurabi, Hittite, and Middle-Assyrian. For a biblical
comparison of Israelite to non-Israelite slavery, read of how Samson and
Zedekiah were treated by their captors (Judges 16:21; 2 Kings 25:7).
The Anchor Bible Dictionary (a liberal-critical scholarly volume) says this
about OT slavery:
"We have in the Bible the first appeals in world
literature to treat slaves as human beings for their own sake and not just
in the interests of their masters... [By comparison] the idea of a slave as
exclusively the object of rights and as a person outside regular society was
apparently alien to the laws of the [rest of the] ... contrast to many
ancient doctrines, the Hebrew law was relatively mild toward the slaves and
recognized them as human beings subject to defense from intolerable acts,
although not to the same extent as free persons."
Israelite servanthood was designed to keep the poor and
disenfranchised from starving. In fact, there were several OT laws given to
prevent enslavement of the poor altogether (Exodus 22:25; Leviticus
5:7,11; 19:9-10; 23:22; 25:36-37; Deuteronomy 15:4-10; 24:20-21).
Slavery was a last resort for those who had no other means of supporting
themselves. It would seem that slavery was never intended to be a permanent
institution and was never regarded by God as ideal. The ultimate goal stated
in the slave laws themselves is that there would be no poverty and no
servanthood in Israel (Deuteronomy 15:1-18). Ideally, each person was to be
his own master (1 Kings 4:25; Micah 4:4; Zechariah 3:10); however,
that was not always possible.
Slavery in
the New Testament
The New Testament writers all lived under the Roman
Empire which sought to institutionalize chattel slavery. In the first
century, it is estimated that 85-90 percent of Rome's population was
enslaved. Slaves were considered their master's property and did not have
legal rights. However, they did have the right to start a business and earn
money with which they could eventually purchase their freedom (manumission)
or purchase property (peculium). This was the world in which the gospel was
first preached.
It is significant that Jesus began his ministry by
connecting it with Israel's Jubilee Year in which all slaves in the land
were set free (Luke 4:18 [Isaiah 61:1]). Jesus came to set all men
free - the ultimate fulfillment of all that the Jubilee Year anticipated!
Yet, Jesus did not set men free by creating an economic reform plan or
establishing a theocratic state that would abolish slavery. Instead, he
addressed the heart problems that brought about slavery and other oppressive
economic social structures. He preached love, mercy, and service towards
others. His intention seems to have been that Christians would influence the
world around them through their example and the preaching of the gospel.
In Christ, all human beings are equal (Galatians
3:28; Colossians 3:11; James 3:9) and slaves, just as much as freedmen,
were regarded as morally responsible persons (Colossians 3:22-25) and
members of Christ's body (1 Timothy 6:2). The New Testament writers
reiterated the Old Testament's condemnation of unlawful slave trading (1
Timothy 1:10; Revelation 18:11-13); however, the institution of slavery
was not specifically condemned. In the New Testament epistles, masters are
commanded to treat their slaves decently and told that God will hold them
accountable for this (Ephesians 6:5ff; Colossians 4:1). Christian
slaves were told to be submissive to their masters and do what is right even
while mistreated (1 Peter 2:18-20). Paul encouraged Christian slaves
to seek their freedom if possible but otherwise be content in their
situation, knowing that "he who was called in the Lord as a bondservant is a
freedman of the Lord" (1 Corinthians 7:17, 20-22).
Critics often fault the New Testament writers for not
directly challenging the institution of slavery. Three things can be said in
response. First, it must be remembered that the first century Christians
lived under the rule of the Roman Empire whose economy was based on slave
labor. To directly oppose the emperor and abolish slavery in the empire
would have been impossible. Second, violent political reform was not the
Christian method of doing things. Though the message of Christianity
directed opposed many of Rome's institutions, there is no indication that
Jesus expected his followers to oppose them with force. Third, the New
Testament's position on slavery was defiantly countercultural for its day!
No other philosopher or group preached the equality of slaves with their
masters. For slaves and freedmen to partake of a communion meal together (as
in 1 Corinthians 11:17-34) was a revolutionary act which shattered
Rome's existing social structures.
Conclusion
Though slavery was not an ideal institution, many
ancient peoples believed it to be necessary. The Law of Moses made
modifications to this already-existing institution to ensure that slaves
were treated fairly and humanely. In many ways, slavery in Israel was
actually an attractive means to help the poor avoid starvation. While it is
true that the New Testament does not outright condemn all forms of slavery
(it does condemn the Roman slave trade), under the new law in Christ all
human beings are considered equal in the church.
That this ideal of equality was not perfectly practiced
for much of Christian history is undeniable. It is also true that racial
prejudice still exists among Christians today. However, the gospel did
achieve a gradual leavening effect on society concerning this issue. The
abolition of slavery in the Western world can be directly attributed to the
efforts of Christian churches and evangelical leaders.Even today, the
Christian belief that every human life has inherent value continues to
safeguard against greed, oppression, violence, racism and other evils that
brought about slavery in the first place.
[FOOTNOTE:The abolition movement in Britain was
spearheaded by evangelical William Wilberforce and led to Parliament passing
the Slavery Abolition Act in 1833. This act freed slaves in the West Indies
colonies and reimbursed former slaveholders - a move which nearly bankrupted
the empire. Across the Atlantic, evangelical churches in America soon began
the rallying cry for abolition. Though the faith of President Abraham
Lincoln is a hotly debated subject, there is evidence that his increasing
religious convictions throughout the war informed (and perhaps even
prompted) his decision to push forward the Emancipation Proclamation.
Lincoln is quoted by Salmon Chase as saying "I made a solemn vow before God,
that if General Lee was driven back from Maryland I would crown the result
by the declaration of freedom to the slaves" ["Lincoln's Calvinist
Transformation: Emancipation and War," Civil War History (September 1,
2000)]. For evidence of Lincoln's growing religious convictions during the
war in his own writings see "Meditation on the Divine Will" and his Second
Inaugural speech. Also, see the work of Lincoln biographer Ronald C. White.]
Bibliography
Paul Copan, Is God a Moral Monster? (Grand Rapids:
Baker, 2011).
J.A. Motyer, The Message of Exodus (Downer’s Grove, IL:
InterVarsity, 2005)
Muhammad A. Dandamayev, s.v. "Slavery (Old Testament),"
in Anchor Bible Dictionary, vol. 6, ed. David Noel Freedman (New York:
Doubleday, 1992).
A.A. Ruprecht, s.v. “Slave, Slavery,” in Dictionary of
Paul and His Letters, ed. Gerald Hawthome et al. (Downer’s Grove, IL:
InterVarsity, 1993), 881-83.
D.B. Martin, Slavery as Salvation: The Metaphor of
Slavery in Pauline Christianity (New Haven: Yale University, 1990), 1-49.
Other Articles
A Heart of Wisdom